Today, Chelsea Clinton Became a Journalist

The hiring of Chelsea Clinton by NBC News was greeted with skepticism by some in the news business on Monday.

  1. Journalists have tried and failed for years to interview the famously press-shy Ms. Clinton. And it was no different on Monday, as several journalists pointed out on Twitter:
  2. Ms. Clinton's only comment came in the form of a statement distributed by NBC. In it, she said, "People who imagine and implement solutions to challenges in their own lives, in their communities, in our country and in our world have always inspired me. I hope telling stories through 'Making a Difference' – as in my academic work and non-profit work – will help me to live my grandmother’s adage of 'Life is not about what happens to you, but about what you do with what happens to you.' "
  3. Does it matter that Ms. Clinton declined to comment on the day that she starts a job at a news organization? Erik Wemple, a media blogger for The Washington Post, argued that it does. "If you’re going to interview other people, it might be helpful to have spent a moment or two on the other side of the mike," he wrote Monday afternoon. 
  4. While some discussed her reticence to comment, others homed in on NBC's decision to hire yet another famous family member, with some calling it "nepotism."
  5. Eric Deggans, the television critic for The St. Petersburg Times, had already labeled NBC the "Nepotism Broadcasting Company" for having Kathie Lee Gifford's son Cody review movies on "Today" and for having the late Tim Russert's son, Luke, report on politics for the news division. 

    On Monday Mr. Deggans wrote: "Few doubt that Clinton seems a poised intelligent young woman, especially after growing up in the maelstrom of the Clinton's tumultuous presidency. But I always think it sends an odd message to have high-profile correspondent jobs go to people with little or on TV reporting experience."


    Meanwhile, James Poniewozik of Time magazine made a case for nepotism, writing, "All other things being equal, fame—earned or inherited, deserved or not—quite simply is often an asset for an interviewer. People will sometimes talk to a famous person on camera because they recognize them and there’s an element of comfort."


    Ms. Clinton's name was trending on Twitter for much of the day. Some of the sentiments were supportive of her and her new position...

  6. ...While many other comments were highly critical of NBC:
Like
Share

Share

Facebook
Google+