Frank McDonald and How to Spot a Wrong 'Un

Frank McDonald is an educated individual and concerned with plight of the Palestinians in Gaza, which is to be applauded. However, like many he seems to assume that antisemites don’t exist or don’t have an agenda. In short, he mistakenly retweeted a handful of serious antisemites on Twitter.

bySoupy One1 Like645 Views
Favicon for
Favicon for

  1. I don’t believe Mr McDonald is a racist. He, most certainly, is not an antisemite or anywhere close.

    But like many on social media he suspends his natural cynicism and assumes that everyone retweeting material on Gaza is as pure as the driven snow.

    Mr McDonald didn’t seem to realise that any subject connected to Jews is contested terrain where antisemites exist and try to thrive.

    Obvious question

    Obviously, that begets the question, how to distinguish between those genuinely concerned with the plight of the Palestinians and real antisemites?

    Surprisingly, it’s not that difficult, it involves merely looking in Twitter timelines for critical themes that antisemites argue over and then tallying them up.

    Two examples

    1. A genuine person concerned with the human rights of the Palestinians is unlikely to indulge in Holocaust denial, whereas antisemites will.

    2. Someone sincerely touched by the plight of the Palestinians is unlikely to have a fixation with conspiracy theories and rant on about “Rothschilds” or "Bilderberg", etc but antisemites will.

    It is probably best to illustrate the views of these people and let reasoned individuals, like Mr McDonald, learn the characteristics of antisemites and how to spot them.

    Once more, I do not think Mr McDonald is a racist but has mistakenly let down his guard against antisemitism and those that push it. Mr McDonald is not alone in being taken in by Twitter antisemites or is he going to be the last.

    Distinguishing antisemites from everyone else.

    It is not a complicated process, merely looking out for significant antisemitic themes and their re-occurrence in a particular timeline or exchange on Twitter. Amongst hardened antisemites there is a recurring usage of them, which is not true amongst the normal population.

    That is the method, lookout for unusual antisemitic themes and their regularity.

    In this Storify I shall illustrate the initial tweets, then the cranks behind them and why sensible people avoid them.
  2. There are more, but these few examples should suffice.

    The ideas behind these antisemites


    The culprits are @CharlesFrith @SplottDave @occpal @HamdoDelic and @polticalquest

    Their views range from crazy conspiracy beliefs (obviously blaming Jews for everything bad in the world), 9/11 trutherism (blaming, yes you guessed it), open Holocaust denial to propagandising for White Supremacists.

    I have covered Frith's crackpot ideas and antisemitism before, A bucket of Charles Frith's racism.
  3. @SplottDave

    @SplottDave is a devotee of the neo-Nazi, Jew Watch, and its various anti-Jewish conspiracy theories.
  4. He's fond of weirder ones too.
  5. Naturally, he's friendly with Ian R Millard, a well known Twitter neo-Nazi and keen on Holocaust denial.

  6. @occoal w
    hows an unhealthy preoccupation with anti-Jewish themes and extremist web sites.

  7. @HamdoDelic c
    arries on the old traditional antisemitic themes, Holocaust denial, etc and nothing subtle.
  8. @polticalquest treads the classical antisemitic motifs: Jews as agents of Satan, Khazars and Holocaust revisionism.

    He's also keen on David Duke, ex-Grand Wizard of the Klu Klux Klan.