Just because it's short doesn't mean it's easy
Some thoughts on short stories and how to build one to fit an anthology
- Today, I've edited one short story and am writing another. I didn't sell a short until I'd sold three novels, so here's what I've learned:
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749990296491003904
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:36:35 - 1. A short story can't just be a pretty twist. It *needs* a pretty twist, but it also needs worldbuilding, great characters, and a plot.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749990406910316544
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:37:01 - 2. With <10k words, you don't have time for deep worldbuilding, so lean into collective shorthand to leave room for an actual plot.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749990587751866368
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:37:44 - (By which I mean: You can accomplish more by, "It was just like Narnia" than you can describing every tree and streetlamp. We get it.)
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749990825438896128
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:38:41 - 2. You need a beginning, a middle, a climax, and an ending, all tied together by a theme. You want to make the reader feel something.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749991038605991936
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:39:32 - 3. Some stories are too big for your allowed word count, and that's ok. Find something else you can do small and well. Keep it lean.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749991233351811074
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:40:18 - 4. For short stories, I usually go 2k over the word count, then have to go back in and see where fat can be cut. It's ok to overwrite some.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749991428403695616
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:41:05 - 5. A short story is not a character just talking about shit with a "GOTCHA" moment at the end. It's still a STORY. Plot is important.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749991716481077248
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:42:14 - 6. Short stories can be mastered through practice. My writing group did timed writings to a random theme. I got faster, then I got better.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749992497779208192
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:45:20 - 7. For me, with a short story, I want a GUT PUNCH. Not *just* a story. I want to feel something. Build plot around that moment.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749992689807003648
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:46:06 - 8. You need: Idea, where it starts, plot point 1, climax, GOTCHA, ending. And the plot points should have action verbs, not "learns".
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749993113876369408
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:47:47 - Want me to do that thing where I develop a story in real time? Give me a genre and anthology idea, and I'll come up with a short story.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749993311558070272
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:48:34 - K. So let's pretend this is an anthology I've been invited to. And I want to fit it into my Wake of Vultures world. https://twitter.com/tomknightwrites/status/749993708091641856 …
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749994221818511360
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:52:11 - Because if you're an author with a series, you can find new readers by introducing them to your world in an anthology, right? Right.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749994349874778112
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:52:41 - So I need a story involving a kickass female pirate in my "monsters are real; you see them when you kill one" world. And Nettie Lonesome.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749994523917447168
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:53:23 - I like to pull from the mythology, so let's go with Anne Bonney. She's a monster. But what kind? A selkie, maybe? Looking for her skin.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749995237918011392
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:56:13 - I need to get Nettie to the ocean. Start with her on a ship, grumbling about why all the Rangers are needed to take down one piddly Kraken.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749995509947957248
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:57:18 - Because I need to skip all the "how and why are we here" and get to the moment before their ship is rammed. Not by a Kraken. By Anne.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749995638436294656
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:57:49 - Anne knows a Ranger stole her selkie skin, so she takes them all prisoner. But she doesn't know Nettie is a monster. Nettie transforms...
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749995819630202880
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:58:32 - Escapes her bonds, frees the Rangers, and they storm the ship. But we need a twist. Nettie realizes she's seen the skin lining the cloak...
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749996016913514496
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:59:19 - Of a Ranger! So she gets into a swordfight with Anne and tells her the truth, siding with a woman over the Rangers bc she admires Anne.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749996169800085504
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 15:59:55 - Nettie negotiates the Rangers' release in exchange for the skin. Anne puts it on and dives into the ocean, a seal. Then the Kraken shows up.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749996413468217344
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 16:00:53 - The story ends with Nettie grumbling that she'd rather taken on a goddamn Kraken than one whiney woman who's been wronged.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749996503943569409
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 16:01:15 - So there you have it. An anthology, a world, a character, a problem, it's solved with a twist, and it ends with a WHAT THE HELL?
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749996850447613953
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 16:02:38 - What I ignored in this brainstorm: actual history/age of pirates, how they got here, where they go after. It's a slice. A rabbit punch.
https://twitter.com/DelilahSDawson/status/749997079943143425
— Delilah S. Dawson (@DelilahSDawson)Mon, Jul 04 2016 16:03:32