Theorizing on women, academe, blogging, and power

A story about how women destroy their careers by blogging led me and some tweeps to theorize on how group status, legitimacy shape role of women in social media.

  1. RT @tressiemcphd: How Blogging Is Ruining The Careers of Women bit.ly/UCQpvt Also a valuable read for blogging academics #highered
  2. I think some of the points in that article point to my belief that academics should not be browbeat into blogging/social media #highered
  3. There is some natural selection happening when people gravitate towards social media. Let that happen. #highered
  4. If we disrupt that I fear we force people to engage the medium who are too afraid to do it well; set up for disappointment #highered
  5. @tressiemcphd Esp since social media engagement is not part of T&P criteria. #highered
  6. .@NyashaJunior True. If it would just be another angst inducing chore with no direct tenure connection, then don't do it.
  7. It need not be a value judgement. A woman yesterday shook with fear at the thought of writing a blog post. It exists in "perpetuity".
  8. That woman would be a horrible blogger, maybe even a dangerous one: to herself, to her peace of mind, to her work.
  9. Some of us enjoy doing this, so it's not a burden. And that's OK.
  10. @tressiemcphd Odd. Does an academic article not exist in the same way? Perhaps with more chance of being archived forever?
  11. @tressiemcphd i definitely understand this. it took me a long time to open up my blog. even still, i have anxiety around it...
  12. Since I've had a driver's license a weekly ritual was posting up in a bookstore, randomly selecting books & periodicals and reading them.
  13. Being online gives me that same kind of breadth of exposure to new ideas that I so desperately need to stay motivated.
  14. Being narrow in that typical academic way gives me hives. I feed off this. Thus, it works for me.
  15. @tressiemcphd I think maybe the fear is how much larger the audience can be, & how much more immediate and uncensored, on a blog.
  16. @qui_oui Her follow up comments support your thesis. It was the immediacy. For some reason that really bothered her.
  17. @tressiemcphd Like it needs to be confirmed as good by others before it's made "public" (& of course many journal articles aren't public)
  18. @qui_oui I'm kidding. I'm thinking the issue of needing validation is not one I have, thus, egotistical blogger. I'm sure it helps.
  19. @tressiemcphd I guess it would mean I am egotistical too ;-) Oh well... (this is an interesting issue though, in seriousness!)
  20. @qui_oui Agreed because I suspect it's rooted in out group status. If you've been validated by existing racial-patriarchal+
  21. @qui_oui structures then some blog comments feels like an assault to your entire sense of self. To me, it's like "eh"
  22. @qui_oui So we end up with this bifurcation on social media -- white men accustomed to deserving to be heard
  23. @qui_oui and groups so desperate to be heard they'll take any shot. In the mushy middle are those who kinda benefit from the former
  24. @qui_oui & aren't really the latter. tenuous position in patriarchy so risk of alienation is high, not alienated enough for risk to be worth

Did you find this story interesting? or comment as 2 already did!

Liked!

tressie mc

Sociologist. PhD student. I stan for organizational lit. Professional hell-raiser. I tried to shut up once & it ended badly for all. #EmoryUniversity

Total views
118

Storify

@Storify