"Is he dead or alive?" "It doesn't matter - run it anyway"

Early Thursday, Oct. 20, news broke that former Libyan leader, Moammar Gadhafi had been captured - and it broke first through social media. The most shocking element of the coverage wasn't Gadhafi's death though - it was the widespread release of unconfirmed reports.

  1. Early Thursday, news broke that former Libyan leader, Moammar Gadhafi had been captured; and it rapidly flooded Twitter timelines across the world.


    Worldwide trending topics as of 8:00 a.m. Thursday morning included #Gadhafi, Libyan TV, Sirte (the Libyan city where Gadhafi was reportedly captured), and Abel Majid (the National Transitional Council official who reported Gadhafi was injured to Reuters). 

  2. BREAKING: Gadhafi captured, says military council on Libyan TV: t.co/1nC8gaX6
  3. The breaking news drew attention from across the globe, in the form of tweets in a variety of languages.
  4. RT @zeitonline: Gadhafi soll bei seiner Festnahme ums Leben gekommen sein, meldet Al Jazeera. Livestream: t.co/eICfO0Bh (sh)
  5. The strangest part of it all? Gadhafi's status was not confirmed before the story broke.
  6. Unconfirmed reports former Libyan leader #Gadhafi has been captured. Watch Libya's Al Ahrar network live: http://on.cnn.com/cnndcl1
  7. Conflicting unconfirmed reports on #Gadhafi's condition and status. Rumors quickly spread and get repeated as facts. Best to wait and see
  8. @Poynter reminded reporters of traditional journalism values; such as making sure viewers, listeners, and readers understood what was true and what was still unconfirmed.

  9. Caution: If you're reporting on Gaddafi, attribute info about capture/death so that viewers/readers know what info's confirmed, what's fluid
  10. Released reports each said something different - some outlets said the dictator was captured, some said shot, and others said dead. The seemingly contradicting stories left media watchers confused on what to believe.

  11. Libya officials: Gadhafi captured, possibly killed - USA Today
  12. RT @abususu: overview #gaddafi rumours: 1- wounded, 2- dead by nato, 3- dead but not by nato 4- in critical condition #libya
  13. FLASH: Libya's Gaddafi dies of wounds suffered in capture near Sirte - senior NTC military official
  14. @Reuters confirmed Gadhafi's death early on from only one source. By midmorning, several news organizations had the story leading their broadcasts - but it was still unconfirmed.

  15. THE PROOF? Al Jazeera just shown this image of what they say is a dead #Gadhafi : t.co/r9V0mpTJ
  16. Liking the use of CAPITAL letters re UNCONFIRMED reports of Gaddafi's capture. #Libya
  17. According to Twitter, #gadhafi has been shot, captured, killed, revived, & escaped under 5 different name spellings in the last hour.
  18. One major news organization failed to weigh in on the Gadhafi deaths - The New York Times minimally updated their twitter feed over the course of the morning, as shown in this article from the Columbian Journalism Review.

  19. Libyan Fighters Say Qaddafi Stronghold Has Fallen http://nyti.ms/ovfCFP
  20. NYT NEWS ALERT: Head of Libya’s Military Council Says Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi Is Dead

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!

Samantha Yeh

community @bitly, Columbia Graduate School of Journalism student, aspiring multimedia journalist.

Total views
32

Storify

@Storify