Today's ReadWriteWeb Big Question: Should Apple build its own social network, or focus entirely on supporting other social networks instead?

Dan Frommer wondered if Apple should consider creating a robust social network itself, or if it makes more sense to simple support external social networks. http://rww.to/yApkr2

  1. Alessandro Mencarini  -  Apple is backing Twitter more and more, its integration baked into Mountain Lion shows this and I find it unlikely that they would take another direction.
  2. Arvind Gautam  -  companies can build their own social networks if they wish - BUT they should agree to utilizing a single identity and and connectivity between the different networks. Otherwise it's just a giant fiasco.
  3. Matt Hoyland  -  I'd say this - they've built a walled eco-system for their users with the Iphone/Ipad etc and keep a strict grip on what goes into that environment. As such they have a captive audience faithful to the "brand".

    Surely it would make sense to have their own social network. Problem is that designing desirable shiny hardware is one thing - designing a desireable apple branded social network to compete with Facey/Google+ and Twitter - already well established - is quite another.

    be interesting if they did.
  4. Hari Prasanth  -  It is definitely Apple's responsibility .. All those iFans should take it up to the fruit company so they can change the policies....
  5. wenn - Tweeted News Network  -  As we mentioned on twitter - Good Question - However but "Friends who are using Apple's OS" are a subset of "Friends" and not vice versa. On the other hand it could be a good marketing tool by using your "Apple Friends" to push you so you buy an Apple product in order to not feel discriminated (Well... maybe some ROI study won't justify such choices).
  6. Randy Roberts  -  Honestly do not make your own social network, that would be stupid they failed with the Ping thing n tryin to make music social and there is already too much competition
  7. @RWW you got the name wrong. It will be called iPal
  8. YES! — RT @RWW iPhone Address Book Fiasco Should Be Apple's Cue to Build Its Own Social Network rww.to/yApkr2
  9. @bunch @RWW they can just build right on their iTunes network and membership. Would be sooooo easy.
  10. @fromedome @RWW IMHO Apple can't do social. Full stop. It's not in their genes and you can't buy such DNA at scale. [See: Google]
  11. @RWW I think it should focus on supporting others since we get too many time suckers & most wouldn't want to manage somthing else (IMo)
  12. @jangles @fromedome @RWW Apple has never been able to build a web service to save their lives. Hell, they can't even make Apple ID work.
  13. come to think of it, if apple made a social network, i probably would join, and so would a lot of others @rww #brandpower
  14. Good Q... @RWW: Should Apple build its own social network, or focus on supporting other social networks instead? rww.to/yApkr2
  15. @rww Focus on support for others, Google have already shown the difficulty of competing with Facebook and Twitter
  16. Remember PING? Oh yeah! What's that?“@RWW: Should Apple build its own social network, or focus on supporting other social networks instead?"
  17. @RWW Interesting question - But what is this, that apple could offer by doing it cheaper/better. A network of "My MAC/iOS" friends?
  18. So wrong. I thought Dan Frommer understood Apple. Probably thinks Apple should get a music and TV studio, too. rww.to/yApkr2 via @RWW
  19. iDontWork RT @RWW: Should Apple build its own social network, or focus on supporting other social networks instead? rww.to/yApkr2

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!

ReadWriteWeb

The latest news, analysis and conversation in all things web, tech and social media from the ReadWriteWeb.com team.

Total views
4,479

Storify

@Storify