Hello iPad user! You should definitelydownload and try our free iPad app!

Published (M)

Whose World Cup is it anyway?

  1. The Onion, recently, carried a story that at first glance you would mistakenly assume was true; that it had accidentally wandered off the sports pages of mainstream media onto the spoofy site. Here it is:
  2. Here's where the real world met the world of spoof:
  3. The operative bit? :

    "Beneficiaries of these free tickets included VIP box guests, political parties, senior govt dignitaries, 71 Commonwealth Games Association and Organising Committee Executive Board members, international federations, sports and medical commission, Supreme Court and High Court judges."
  4. Here again is the operative bit:

    The full bore shooting event was held for the first time in India and the CRPF shooting range in Kadarpur was selected as the venue because of availability of open space here. The first-of-its-kind full bore shooting range was built at a cost of Rs 25 crore. 

    After having spent so much of money, officials were expecting a large number of spectators for the five-day event in which 42 players from 21 countries participated. While there were a handful of spectators, most of them were friends and relatives of the organizers and CRPF officials who didnt buy tickets to witness the event. 


  5. All of which brings us to the World Cup. Consider this:

  6. SK Natraj is not an isolated case -- a friend who is part of the BCCI administrative machinery told me the other day that official requests for passes by the hundreds had become the bane of his life. "If I oblige all the requests we are getting, fans will end up standing outside the stadium looking in," was how he put it.

    Elsewhere, over the past couple of weeks, friends have been calling to ask, "Do you know how I can get tickets to ". The short answer? Damned if I know. From all I hear, the rated capacity of most venues means zip -- by the time the hospitality boxes are filled up, the VIP enclosure passes handed out, and sundry other interest groups obliged, the actual capacity has come down to half, or less.

    All of this put me in mind of Dave Zirin's book Bad Sports -- and this very eloquent prologue, from which an extensive quote follows (Emphasis on selected lines mine):

  7. In the 21st century, far too many sports fans
    have a headache that is rapidly entering migraine territory. It is not just the
    1,440 minutes of televised sports coverage that is doing the damage. It is not
    even the sports talk radio blabbocracy that is making people reach for the
    Extra Strength Tylenol. The headache comes from the feeling that we are loving
    something that does not love us in return.
    If sports was once like a playful
    puppy you would wrestle on the floor, it is now like a housecat demanding to be
    stroked and giving nothing back in return.
     
    …..
     
    Fun has become pain, and sports have become expendable. … In
    my mind, this is a tragic state of affairs.  How did sports become so overbearing
    in our culture, and yet so distant from our personal embrace? When, as fans,
    did we develop the equivalent of the battered spouse’s syndrome?
    And who
    is at fault for this state of affairs?
     
    ….
     
    It is the owners who need to answer for this sorry state of
    affairs. Players play. Fans watch. Owners are uniquely charged with being the
    stewards of the game. It is a task they have failed to perform in spectacular
    fashion.
     
    These are the caretakers, and yet, with barely a sliver of
    scrutiny, they are wrecking the world of sports. The old model of the
    paternalistic owner caring for a community has become as outdated as the Model
    T. Because of publicly funded stadium construction, luxury box licenses,
    sweetheart cable deals, globalized merchandizing plans, and other “revenue
    streams”, the need for owners to cater to a local working- and middle-class fan
    base has shrunk dramatically. Fans have become
    scenery for television broadcasts.

     
    The fastest growing sector of fans? People who love sports,
    but hate what they are becoming. …
     
    Whether you are a sports fan or not, sports affects the
    national discussion and economy like never before. It shapes how we understand
    our cultural landscape and is a prime economic player in the game of urban
    politics. It also rests under a dizzying maze of antitrust exemptions and
    secrecy like no other business of comparable size. The reason why the bulk of
    owners are unknown, hiding in the darkness, is that the light is kind neither
    to them nor their spreadsheets.
     
    ….
     
    We shouldn’t expect sports owners to reform out of the
    goodness of their hearts. They represent corporations trying to max out every
    last cent. But it is one thing when we pay insane ticket prices and then also
    shell out money for both parking at the stadium and the shuttle to get from the
    parking lot to the stadium entrance. But that is still our choice. It is
    another thing altogether when the owners both call for and receive public funds
    and taxpayer dollars. We need to insist that by taking our dollars, they are
    entering into an unspoken agreement not just with the various mayors, governors
    or political lackeys eager to lick some sweet salt off the rim, but also the citizens
    themselves. One theme we will return to over and over in the following pages is
    that if our dollars are to be used, we must have some say in the way the teams
    are operated. One of the fans I interviewed, James Generic, said to me, “I
    can’t stand how the owners extort money from the public on the stadiums and
    then charge freaking seven dollars for a glass of beer.”
     
    …..
     
    Mike Lupica of the New York Daily News once wrote: “You are
    owed nothing in sports, no matter how much you care. You are owed nothing no
    matter how long you’ve rooted or how much you’ve paid to do it.” I couldn’t
    disagree more. We are owed plenty by the athletic industrial complex. We are
    owed loyalty. We are owed accessibility. We are owed a return on our massive
    civic investment. And more than anything, we should raise our fists to the
    owners’ box and say that we are owed a little bit of goddamn respect. We aren’t
    owed this respect because it is the kind or the human thing to do. We aren’t
    owed any love because we cheered ourselves hoarse and passed the precious
    rooting tradition down to our children. We are owed it because the teams are
    ours as much as they are theirs. Literally. By calling for and receiving public
    funds, owners have sacrificed their moral, if not financial, claim of
    ownership. It is unrealistic to expect owners to behave better on their own
    recognizance, but cities and city councils that hand over funds to the sports
    plutocracy should in turn have some say in the way the teams are operated.
     
    As Jesse Barton, a former assistant city manager in Coos
    Bay, Oregon, said to me, “If the teams are truly a public good, government
    should acquire appropriate equity stakes in the teams in which they invest. But
    the owners virtually always resist that. The reason they resist is that the
    owners know that fundamentally, their teams aren’t a type of public good. They
    know that instead, their teams are a business that serves a particular segment
    of society, and not the society in general.”
     
    The last goal of this book is to ask the question: whose
    games are these, anyway? Are they the property of owners who let us watch for a
    price, or are they ours, and owners should merely play the role of caretaker
    for the generation of fans who animate their games?
     
    …..
     
    The classic Coen brothers’ movie Miller’s Crossing includes
    a line where the world weary Tom says to the crime boss, Leo, “You only run
    this town because the people think you run it. The minute they stop thinking
    it, you stop running it.”. The first step is bringing these titans of the
    luxury box down to earth. Up close the flaws become craters, and the steps we
    need to take crystallize as we conceive of reclaiming the games we love.

    This question affects all of us whether we see ourselves as
    sports fans or not, and the cost of not holding ownership accountable can prove
    deadly.

  8. In passing, I am experimenting with a new way of telling stories, using Storify, for which I got the Beta invite only this morning. 

    E&OE, hence -- bear with me till I get the toy working the way I want it to.

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!
Total views
1972