Discussion capture: Flexible, malleable content management systems

  1. Dear Santa – What I really want is a *content management system* that is as infinitely flexible, malleable, as the web. Thanks m #wcchi
  2. In Erin Kissane's An Event Apart talk, she talked "about the principles of craft and how they apply to creating systems that support effective content startegy." Here's Luke Wroblewski's notes:
  3. Any CMS in particular you're upset with? RT @brad_frost: Content management systems are horrible. @kissane #aea
  4. .@marsinthestars In my talk, I harshed on the early generations of clunky CMSes—but noted that we’re making progress on new ones. #aeadc
  5. So, I am asking for a better system. What would that better system look like? Again …
  6. Dear Santa – What I really want is a *content management system* that is as infinitely flexible, malleable, as the web. Thanks m #wcchi
  7. I am adding the discussion as it unfolds:
  8. @mirandamulligan you need just web addressable content and a metadata management system that can decorate it.
  9. @mirandamulligan a CMS that pre-defines what content should be, will always fail
  10. @mirandamulligan the idea is that the content can be anything and on the web, all you need to manage is metadata, navigation and embedding
  11. @mirandamulligan the C in CMS should be 'Curation' and not 'Content,' you need a Curation Management System over any web reachable content
  12. @mirandamulligan @gridinoc um, flexibility is directly disproportional of functionality. You give one up when you incr. another
  13. @mirandamulligan @gridinoc ultimately, the most flexible CMS has no features and vice-versa, more powerful the CMS, less flexible it is.
  14. @inadarei Can you expand? It sounds like you are referencing a flexible system is a dumb one. +@gridinoc
  15. @mirandamulligan it's a system design law: any feature introduces an assumption & limits flexibility. So you have to compromise. @gridinoc
  16. @mirandamulligan @gridinoc case in point: Jekyll (github.com/mojombo/jekyll) is way less design-limiting than WP or Drupal but has few features.
  17. @inadarei @mirandamulligan yup, agree; but I would like to disconnect as much as possible the content from the management bit...
  18. @mirandamulligan @gridinoc you can try to build for edge cases and mimic flexibility, but that easily leads to uber-complexity and bloat.
  19. @gridinoc disconnecting Editorial UI from user presentation is an excellent approach which also increases security. @mirandamulligan
  20. @gotoplanb @mirandamulligan imagine a @storify where you can customise how you manage what you refer to, like having your own embed.ly

Did you find this story interesting? or comment as 1 already did!

Liked!

Miranda Mulligan

I am a journalist running on 90% caffeine and 10% water and currently the digital design director at The Boston Globe. I Pixar tweets.

Total views
132

Storify

@Storify