Reaction to AP retweet guidelines

  1. This was our first tweet from @Poynter:
  2. AP issues retweet guidelines to staff: journ.us/s1kbmE No personal opinions are allowed or implied; 'we’re simply reporting it'
  3. What followed was a lot of criticism. Many people argued that the AP guidelines suggest a using a confusing style that puts the "RT" at the very beginning, separated from the username. Like this:

           RT Jones campaign now denouncing smith on education: @jonescampaign smith’s policies would destroy our schools
  4. @tjrkent Separating RT from @name breaks the chain of custody. It won't be clear whose words are being reshared without adding quotes.
  5. Setting aside whether the AP's new Twitter guidelines are dumb or not, who places the "RT" where the AP suggests? bit.ly/t1vp0n
  6. Associated Press does a two-fer -- maintains the dumb "no opinions" policy and gets retweet etiquette wrong: is.gd/k1vCXM
  7. AP's Standards Editor Tom Kent did respond to that on Twitter, saying he was OK with doing retweets the other way.
  8. Some saying "RT" belongs after comment of the RT'er, not before. We're OK with either if meaning is clear bit.ly/tOV4l9
  9. Others implied that the new guidelines were too restrictive.
  10. I'm wondering if I RT @amuhs, the AP goblins will come and snatch me away. So much uncertainty in the world these days. undefined
  11. We'd like to bid adieu to all the cool AP staffers in the Twin Cities on Twitter... see.sc/DeIA7w
  12. AP retweet guidelines also encourage "rt isn't an endorsement" in your Twitter bio. Me: An homage to lawyers. Again, I'll pass.
  13. AP to staff: Don't retweet anything with an opinion. bit.ly/rKbgDE Good luck with that.
  14. AP spokesman Paul Colford said the agency doesn't prohibit retweeting opinions, it just wants its journalists to be clear about attributing the opinion to the source.
  15. @carr2n David, RE yours: "AP to staff: Don't retweet anything with an opinion." Not true. New RT guideline gives ways to do just that.
  16. And a few people decided to follow the spirit of the guidelines in their own retweets:
  17. I am sharing this with absolutely no concern with whether or not you think I'm endorsing the AP policy. :) poynter.org/latest-news/ro… via @AddThis
  18. This doesn't constitute endorsement. MT @davidjoachim: AP issues staff guidelines on retweets; no ‘personal opinions’: bit.ly/v2LvBb
  19. I pass this link along without expressing an opinion one way or another: poynter.org/latest-news/ro…
  20. Some have called it hilarious, I report. RT @carr2n: AP to staff: Don't retweet anything with an opinion. bit.ly/rKbgDE
  21. great/terrible policy I don't think RT @carr2n: AP to staff: Don't retweet anything with an opinion bit.ly/rKbgDE Good luck with that

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!

Jeff Sonderman

Work: Digital Media Fellow at The Poynter Institute. I tweet mobile/social journalism, technology.

Total views
16,969

Storify

@Storify