Big Society - a critical reappraisal (2)

Tweets and chat from panel discussion at #3srps Third Sector policy and research seminar, 12 December 2011 Thanks to @ESRC @NCVO and @3sectorrc

  1. At #3srps #bigsociety seminar at NCVO. Lots of empirically grounded, well-considered stuff coming out, both -ve & +ve in current context.
  2. Action resumes with panel responses to the presentations. First up is @karlwilding, head of policy, research and foresight @NCVO #3srps
  3. @karlwilding #3srps. Less scope for infrastructure bodies advocacy role in the future? That's depressing is its the case.
  4. KW: Community Organisers are new part of the political debate, thanks to BigSociety ow.ly/7Wvj0 < what would Alinsky think? #3srps
  5. And @karlwilding making interesting comments about whether transferred leisure services have transparency and accountability issues #3srps
  6. Karl Wilding: many larger charities are the size of a Local Authority's social services dept. Does gov. get these issues of scale/capacity?
  7. KW: New aspects of Big Society debate include opendata, new technologies, localism and social innovation < big changes in policy talk #3srps
  8. KW ends on +ive note - sector still strong at the grassroots, legacy of capacity building over last 10 yrs #3srps
  9. Next up is Anna Coote, head of social policy @theneweconomics, focusing on increasing inequalities of community capacity & resources #3srps
  10. RT @commutiny: Coote: We should not shift away from taxation as we cannot rely on philanthropy to be fair, evenly distributed or be on the increase #3srps
  11. Coote: We should not shift away from taxation as we cannot rely on philanthropy to be fair, evenly distributed or be on the increase #3srps
  12. RT @commutiny: Coote: We need transition to a new social settlement which releases & deploys everyday human resources, not current BigSociety model #3srps
  13. Next up is @RSAMAtthew explaining why progressives need to present a new vision of the Big Society #3srps
  14. "Pro-Social Behaviour: the Future - it’s up to us" ow.ly/7WxHt < interesting, relevant essay by @RSAMatthew #3srps
  15. Matthew Taylor on the paradox of entitlement - it doesn't work if we treat it as such: the welfare state doesn't work without a work ethic
  16. RT @commutiny: Says @RSAMatthew "We need to make public services feel like they are outgrowths of the community rather than tentacles of the state" #3srps
  17. Matthew Taylor: any type of Big Society requires a 'generational shift', a 'different model of citizenship' and 'distributional realism'
  18. RT @commutiny: 2007 talk "Bridging the Social Aspiration Gap" ow.ly/7Wy9p < requires govt regs, biz commitment, citizen & consumer action #3srps
  19. Jeremy Vincent (CLG): for gov., there are 3 pillars to the Big Society: social action, community empowerment and opening up public services
  20. Jeremy Vincent, CLG - talking community right to challenge, right to bid for assets, community budgets - #important but #dull #3srps
  21. Audience Q: What training is in place for civil servants expected to facilitate local community activity? A: It's largely on-the-job #3srps
  22. #3srps. Civl servant 'that's a challenge' replying to Q abt ensuring aggregated contracts don't stifle vol sector advocacy role.
  23. A litany of problems with policy initiatives and worries about "the growth of a new underclass"< challenge to "complacent" academics #3srps
  24. Is today's academic debate relevant? Case studies take ages to develop and learn from. Are our speakers living in ivory towers? #3srps

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!

Roxanne Persaud

Sociopreneurial Knowmad, #ThirdSector Pracademic, Amplifier, Positive Disruptor, Motivational Questioner, Network Weaver, #FRSA geek, Maid of Fail. For Hire.

Total views
46

Storify

@Storify