Conversations

Can We Right the Wrongs of Health Reporting a la Aaron Sorkin?

Aaron Sorkin is returning to TV with a show called, "The Newsroom." He believes television news has lost its direction. When I read the NYT's story about the show I wondered, have we lost our way with how we report on health, wellness and prevention efforts?

  1. Those of you who know me at least moderately well understand I've become increasingly concerned about how we're reporting findings from "studies" around health, wellness and prevention. Cited research often includes meta-analyses of the literature, or case studies from which we cannot infer statistical significance, or - worse yet - surveys. 

    Of even more concern to me is the "file-drawer effect," which refers to researchers who file away studies with negative outcomes - meaning they do not report the results from studies that contradict either the researchers' hypotheses or commonly-held beliefs. I think this trend to hold back research results is a dangerous one and leads us to repeat mistakes others made who came before us.

    There are health writers and health care professionals who are trying to educate the public about the mis-reporting of health stories, including Gary Schwitzer (@garyschwitzer) of Health News Review, @Medskep, Howard Luks (@hjluks) and Bob Merberg (@WellWork).

    My new commitment is to ask every person with whom I have the privilege to interview or interact not only about their current work but about their greatest failure. You know what I mean. That great idea that simply didn't pan out.

    My belief - perhaps it is a call-to-action - is that all of us need to become more educated students of the health, medical and wellness / prevention literature. We need to read both research and media reports with a scientifically-critical eye. And, we need to carefully only share, tweet, +1 and "like" stories that hold up to scrutiny. Or, if we share stories with limited statistical significance, that we point out the weakness in the work as we see it.

    And, maybe - just maybe, we can do it in a way that's as entertaining, fun and interesting as Aaron Sorkin.

  2. Mr. Sorkin recited the sins of the news-gathering business, whether trumpeting “what happened last night on ‘Dancing With the Stars’ or, more tragically and much more harmful, turning the Casey Anthony trial into a reality show, which just makes us meaner and dumber.”

    Believing that a crucial institution had lost direction, Mr. Sorkin responded the only way he knew how: by creating a TV show about it.

    “The Newsroom,” his first new series in nearly six years, allows him once again to ply his signature style — brainy, verbose, idealistic — on a weekly, hourlong basis and to right wrongs big and small

Did you find this story interesting? or comment as 1 already did!

Liked!

Carol Harnett

Speaker. Writer. Health and Disability Consultant. Trendspotter. Corporate Storyteller. Crowdsourcer. Traveler. Hawaii & Surf Lover. My tweets are my own.

Total views
102

Storify

@Storify