by
Mon, Dec 12 2011 07:12:38

Dishful Thinking

Whether it's a Hot Fudge Mary Jane from Rennebohm's or those famous guerilla cookies sold at the Mifflin St Co-Op, we want to know: what's the #1 (now-extinct, can't get it anywhere) food or dish that reminds you of your years at University of Wisconsin-Madison?

  1. Jean E Ford
    Jean E Ford
    Bucky burger at Rennies
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:36:10
  2. Kim Steingraeber Ranum
    Kim Steingraeber Ranum
    i miss rennebohm's : , (
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:37:37
  3. Tim Sizer
    Tim Sizer
    ‎3 for $1.00 tacos at the same Rennebohm's lunch counter.
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:37:52
  4. Dan Tremmel
    Dan Tremmel
    Pelmeni!!!
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:39:34
  5. Julie Popper
    Julie Popper
    it has to be the HUGE burritos at the Rathskeller. That or the amazing sandwiches at the shop that used to be across from Noodles & CO on State Street (until that huge new performing arts center forced it out).
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:39:55
  6. Genny Colby
    Genny Colby
    I just miss rennebohm's.
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:40:11
  7. Sara Mikolajczak
    Sara Mikolajczak
    Pelmeni, by far.
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:40:19
  8. Debra Block Malki
    Debra Block Malki
    Chili on the Union Terrace!
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:40:57
  9. DeAnna Friedman
    DeAnna Friedman
    Radical Rye!
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:41:29
  10. Tess Guida
    Tess Guida
    Chocolate Coyote's spicy hot chocolate icecream!
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:42:57
  11. Tom Wilson
    Tom Wilson
    Gyros at Zorba's by the boat booth.
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:43:53
  12. Sue Reilly
    Sue Reilly
    Tim and I LOVED Hot Fudge Mary Janes!!
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:47:59
  13. Chris Weiland
    Chris Weiland
    The original Dotty Dumplings, Pelmini, Radical Rye, and the Parthenon when Gus managed it and it wasn't nearly $10.
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:52:07
  14. Jennifer Basile
    Jennifer Basile
    Milano at Milans or beer battered pickles from JT Whitneys
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:52:58
  15. Amanda Yeschick
    Amanda Yeschick
    Sandwiches at the Radical Rye!
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:53:56
  16. Scott Driskill
    Scott Driskill
    Cheeseburger and special made Cherry Coke at Meriter Methodist.
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:54:26
  17. Chad Wilkes
    Chad Wilkes
    Zorbas and the rossino's pizza cart on langdon at 2am (not sure if that's still there or not)
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 07:59:13
  18. Sean Flyr
    Sean Flyr
    A Grabber from Cellar Subs
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:02:22
  19. Mike Felt
    Mike Felt
    Zorbas gyro
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:04:21
  20. James Eutizzi
    James Eutizzi
    i agree with Sean, Cellar Subs still is the best sub I ever had.
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:11:28
  21. Joe Richie
    Joe Richie
    pel meni and radical rye
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:13:28
  22. Heidi Solberg Viar
    Heidi Solberg Viar
    Yup, Zorba's gyros...and the cheeseburger and fries at the Shed on campus. BTW where is the Chocolate Shoppe now?
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:13:37
  23. Mary Johnson Anderson
    Mary Johnson Anderson
    The donut place that opened in the wee hours of the morning, and the Badger Tavern
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:16:21
  24. Carol Cross
    Carol Cross
    Another Rennebohm staple - grilled danish drowning in butter
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:34:21
  25. Catrine Machi
    Catrine Machi
    Radical Rye sandwiches! The bread was soooo amazing!
    Fri, Dec 09 2011 08:56:01

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!

Wisconsin Alumni

Bucky Badger and Wisconsin Alumni Association, friends of UW-Madison alumni everywhere

15stories
19followers
18following
Total views
136

Sorry.

This URL is already in use. Please choose another URL.
Edit URL

Storify

@Storify

Are you sure?

Are you sure you want to delete this story?

Are you sure?

Are you sure you want to flag this story?