Is Twitter's censorship policy a good one?

Debating Twitter's censorship policy.

  1. I linked to and endorsed my colleague Paul Smalera's post about Twitter censorship which elicited some dissenting responses in terms of how lightly we should take or accept Twitter's new censorship policy.
  2. If you haven't already seen it, @smalera's reasoned analysis of the Twitter censorship fury is a must read reut.rs/xEcIha
  3. @AntDeRosa "grow up" and accept censorship as a given? So condescending, & doesn't address why this is happening: staff+offices overseas.
  4. @AntDeRosa the difference in reactions from US press and those in MX, mideast, etc is notable. Surprised so many here are eager to defend.
  5. @AntDeRosa some important points missing in the piece, and your defense. It's an issue because of physical expansion to foreign countries.
  6. @xeni Countries are going to block Twitter entire without this, it's almost as if Twitter ran an end around on them with this policy
  7. @blogdiva @xeni the "grow up" comment was a bit gratuitous but point is that Twitter just made it easier to point out what is being censored
  8. @AntDeRosa if Twitter were only subject to US laws, this would be non-issue. Once physically inside another nation, another matter.
  9. @AntDeRosa clarification: not having a physical location and on-the-ground staff in speech-hostile countries.
  10. @AntDeRosa last I checked, Twitter was already used by people around the world, despite not having offices/staff in each nation.
  11. @AntDeRosa the EFF piece dug into some of what I'm highlighting here. We may write a bit more about the lost nuances on BB soon, too.
  12. @blogdiva @xeni one big concern for me though is that it removes an early warning system for those in the countries doing the blocking
  13. @blogdiva @xeni the only real reason for Twitter to censor is so they can have offices in these foreign countries
  14. @AntDeRosa I do agree the partnership w/@ChillingEffects is good, & more than Facebook would do, etc. Still doesn't make this positive news.
  15. @blogdiva @xeni the trade off is not having Twitter in that country at all, so which is better?
  16. @AntDeRosa nothing. But then, Twitter would not be taking an active role in censorship.

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!

Anthony De Rosa

Social Media Editor @ Reuters. Neighborhoodr.com Co-Founder. Retweets are not endorsements. Tips and news appreciated, send to [email protected]

Total views
556

Storify

@Storify