Education

The Controversy Behind Teacher Evaluations

  1. .@NewsHourAmGrad challenge: Can you explain, in 140 characters or less, the controversy behind #teacher evaluations?
  2. @NewsHourAmGrad Bloomberg thinks he knows better than teachers how to evaluate teaching ability, and teachers know that he doesn't.
  3. @NewsHourAmGrad If you teach very bright students, they never improve very much -- 99th percentile to start, 99th to end, Teacher failed.
  4. @NewsHourAmGrad easy: the extreme focus on #standardized #test results, as opposed to critical thinking skills. We're raising #drones.
  5. @NewsHourAmGrad In Seattle, the MAP test is being used to evaluate teachers when it specifically states it is not for that purpose.
  6. @NewsHourAmGrad The only people qualified to evaluate the performance of a profession as grinding and nuanced as teaching? Veteran teachers.
  7. @NewsHourAmGrad don't do that. It belittles and oversimplifies the controversy. It's not about something you can say in 140 characters.
  8. @NewsHourAmGrad I can. Tests measure combination of student test-taking talent & recall, not teaching or teacher effectiveness
  9. @newshouramgrad If you're grading teachers based on the performance of their students, don't forget to evaluate the parents as well.
  10. @newshouramgrad Ace student with high scores experiences life-changing event (like divorce) Scores plummet. Teacher fails.
  11. @NewsHourAmGrad District force-implements a new-fangled "Common Core" curriculum with little or no PD. Students struggle. Teachers fail.
  12. @NewsHourAmGrad Hyper-focused on assessment and subsequent eval, teacher dumps STEAM to focus exclusively on Common Core. Students tune out.
  13. @NewsHourAmGrad testing tests test taking ability, that is all, not understanding or knowledge, motivation, hunger.
  14. @NewsHour @NewsHourAmGrad Evals done by people w/o sufficient/relevant experience, etc. My evaluator taught MS math; I teach HS ELA.
  15. @NewsHour @NewsHourAmGrad Encourages competition between teachers when jobs and livelihoods are on the line. Deadly. We must be allies.
  16. @newshouramgrad The common wisdom (is) that measurable outcomes are the least significant result of learning (McNeill, 1986).
  17. Have a better answer? Tweet it to @newshouramgrad.

Did you find this story interesting? Be the first to or comment.

Liked!

NewsHour AmeriGrad

A public media initiative with @AmeriGrad, @NewsHour & more. @chenk_x & the AmGrad team behind the scenes.

Total views
429

Storify

@Storify